- VoIP-Forum - https://www.voip-forum.com -

Robert Sparks on the importance of John Postel’s robustness principle

Posted By oej On February 27, 2010 @ 8:48 In IETF standards & drafts,Open Source | Comments Disabled

Jon Postel captured an approach to make the Internet a more robust place for applications to live in – and added it to RFC793 (the definition of TCP at the time) :

“TCP implementations will follow a general principle of robustness: be conservative in what you do, be liberal in what you accept from others.”.

Robert Sparks has written an article on the SIP Sessions blog about the importance of this for SIP implementations. And he should know. Robert has been managing 25 interoperability sessions with SIP developers. Endless patience with developers that claim that their interpretation of the RFC is correct and that the other side is damn wrong and that’s exactly the reason why their implementation fails the call, the registration or the chat session. I’ve heard Robert saying to me and others many, many times something like: “Yes, there is an issue here, but your app should be more generous and try to handle the situation.” Robert summarizes his thoughts this way:

“Real systems will have imperfections. Systems that use the robustness principle make it less likely that those imperfections will result in failure. Introducing elements that don’t follow the principle negates that robustness, and in real systems,  will cause those systems to fail.”

Read this article named “The Robustness Principle Has Two Parts” [1]  [1]


Article printed from VoIP-Forum: https://www.voip-forum.com

URL to article: https://www.voip-forum.com/opensource/2010-02/robert-sparks-importance-john-postels-robustness-principle-2/

URLs in this post:

[1] Read this article named “The Robustness Principle Has Two Parts”: http://blog.tekelec.com/blog/bid/11600/The-Robustness-Principle-Has-Two-Parts?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+SIPSessions+%28SIP+Sessions%29

Copyright © 2008-2011 Edvina AB, Sollentuna Sweden. All rights reserved.